When Love Feels Like a Game: Can a Narcissist Actually Stay Loyal


I used to believe that love could change anyone. I thought if I was patient, loyal, and understanding enough, he’d eventually commit truly and fully. But what I didn’t realize then was that narcissists view relationships very differently from the rest of us.

When you’re dating a narcissist, faithfulness isn’t really about love or loyalty it’s about control, attention, and ego. They crave admiration like oxygen, and when one person’s attention starts to feel “too normal,” they start searching for it elsewhere.

It took me a long time (and a lot of heartbreak) to understand that a narcissist’s version of commitment isn’t built on emotional connection it’s built on how much supply they can get. In this post, I’ll share the truth about narcissists and faithfulness, why they struggle with real intimacy, and how to spot the red flags before you lose yourself trying to earn their loyalty.

Who Are Narcissists?

Before tackling the question of faithfulness, let’s start by understanding who narcissists are. Narcissism is more than just someone being self-centered or vain. It’s a personality trait that exists on a spectrum, and at its extreme, it can lead to Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD).

Key characteristics of narcissists include:

  • A deep need for admiration and validation
  • A lack of empathy for others
  • A sense of entitlement
  • Manipulative tendencies

Not every narcissist has NPD, but even those with strong narcissistic traits often exhibit similar patterns of behavior in relationships.

What Faithfulness Means in Relationships

Faithfulness isn’t just about avoiding infidelity. It also means being emotionally present, honest, and supportive. For most people, faithfulness stems from a mix of emotional connection, moral values, and a sense of responsibility toward their partner.

For narcissists, however, their understanding of relationships is often transactional. They see people as sources of validation rather than equal partners. This outlook can make sustaining faithfulness a challenge.

Why Narcissists Struggle With Commitment

1. They Prioritize Their Needs Over Others

At their core, narcissists are driven by their own needs. Whether it’s attention, admiration, or power, their primary focus is themselves. Relationships, for them, are tools to fulfill these needs. When the relationship no longer serves them—or when they find a shinier object of admiration—they might stray.

2. The Thrill of the Chase

Narcissists thrive on novelty and excitement. The early stages of a relationship, with its flurry of admiration and attention, feed their ego. But once the relationship stabilizes, they may grow bored and seek that thrill elsewhere. Faithfulness requires consistency, which doesn’t align well with their craving for newness.

3. Lack of Empathy

Empathy is the cornerstone of emotional connection in a relationship. Without it, understanding the hurt caused by infidelity or emotional neglect becomes nearly impossible. Narcissists often dismiss or downplay their partner’s feelings, which can lead to patterns of betrayal.

4. Fear of Vulnerability

Despite their outward confidence, narcissists often have deep insecurities. Faithfulness requires vulnerability—being open and honest with a partner. For narcissists, showing vulnerability feels like losing control, which they’re unlikely to risk.

Also Read: Are Narcissists Really Smarter? Debunking the Myth

Can Narcissists Ever Be Faithful?

The short answer? It depends. While narcissists face significant barriers to faithfulness, there are exceptions. Here’s what can influence their behavior:

1. Self-Awareness and Therapy

Narcissists who recognize their patterns and commit to therapy can work on developing healthier relationship behaviors. Therapy helps them address their insecurities, build empathy, and understand the value of true emotional intimacy.

2. A Partner Who Sets Boundaries

Partners who establish and enforce strong boundaries can sometimes navigate relationships with narcissists successfully. Clear consequences for crossing lines may deter infidelity or manipulative behavior. However, this requires immense emotional strength and self-awareness from the partner.

3. Personal Growth

While rare, some narcissists undergo significant personal growth that shifts their priorities. This might be triggered by life events, such as a major loss or a health crisis. These moments can prompt them to value deeper connections over superficial validation.

Signs a Narcissist Might Be Cheating

Faithfulness isn’t just about what someone says; it’s about their actions. If you’re in a relationship with a narcissist and suspect infidelity, here are some red flags to watch for:

  • Constant need for attention: If they’re always seeking admiration from others, it might indicate trouble.
  • Excessive secrecy: Hiding their phone, being vague about their whereabouts, or avoiding direct questions are common signs.
  • Sudden changes in behavior: A shift in how they treat you—whether they’re overly attentive or distant—can signal they’re diverting their focus elsewhere.
  • Defensiveness: Narcissists often react with anger or deflection when questioned about their actions.

How to Protect Yourself in a Relationship With a Narcissist

If you’re dealing with a narcissist, your well-being must come first. Here’s how to navigate such a relationship:

1. Set Boundaries

Make it clear what you will and won’t tolerate. Narcissists are skilled at pushing limits, so consistent enforcement is key.

2. Seek Support

Talking to friends, family, or a therapist can help you process your emotions and gain perspective. Dealing with a narcissist can be isolating, so don’t hesitate to reach out.

3. Recognize Patterns

Understanding the narcissist’s behavior patterns can help you avoid falling into their traps. This knowledge gives you the power to respond thoughtfully rather than react emotionally.

4. Decide What You Want

Not all relationships with narcissists are doomed, but they often require significant effort. Assess whether the relationship aligns with your values and long-term happiness. Sometimes, walking away is the healthiest choice.

Final Thoughts: The Complex Truth About Narcissists and Faithfulness

So, can narcissists commit? The answer is nuanced. While their personality traits make faithfulness challenging, it’s not entirely impossible. Narcissists who are willing to work on themselves can learn to build healthier relationships, but this requires significant effort and self-awareness.

For those involved with a narcissist, understanding their behavior is crucial. Armed with this knowledge, you can make informed decisions about your relationship and prioritize your emotional health.

In the end, faithfulness isn’t just about staying loyal—it’s about creating a connection built on trust, respect, and mutual understanding. With narcissists, achieving this can feel like an uphill battle, but knowing the truth helps you approach the journey with clarity and confidence.

Also Read: Breaking Up with a Narcissist: The 6 Stages and Long-Lasting Effects You Need to Know

Should I Get Back With My Ex

WAIT, DO YOU STILL HAVE A CHANCE?

Find out your chances of getting your ex back in 2 minutes.

RUP Team
About RUP Team

The RUP Team is a passionate group of relationship experts dedicated to helping you understand love and relationships. As a team, we provide insightful dating advice, practical relationship tips, and a range of content to help you build stronger, healthier connections. Let the RelationUp Team be your guide for improving communication, strengthening bonds, and finding love.

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment